Kitchen Watcher Search

Kitchen Watcher earns a commission when you buy through links on this page. It never changes what we recommend or how we rank it. How we make money

Air Fryer vs Convection Oven: What Actually Differs

An air fryer is a small, fast convection oven. See how fan, heat, capacity and oven air-fry modes compare, per GE, Frigidaire and Consumer Reports.

By Maksud · Published

An air fryer is a countertop convection oven. Both use a heating element and a fan to move hot air, so the air fryer vs convection oven difference is size and intensity, not technology. The air fryer puts its element and fan right above a small basket, which is why it crisps small batches faster, per Nebraska Extension and Prudent Reviews. A convection oven holds far more food and bakes on several racks.

Kitchen Watcher compiles manufacturer documentation and independent test results; we did not cook with these appliances. See how we research.

Is an air fryer a convection oven?

Yes, in how it heats food. Nebraska Extension describes an air fryer as cooking by moving very hot air around food, which is convection cooking. Its heating element sits above the food and a fan moves the air quickly.

Consumer Reports agrees: convection, hot air moved by one or more fans, is the same technology behind countertop air fryers. CR adds that a little oil on the food also transfers heat by direct contact. Prudent Reviews says air fryers cook faster than convection toaster ovens because the chamber is smaller and sealed, the element is closer to the food and the fan blows faster.

So an air fryer is not a separate heating method, and it does not fry in a vat of oil. Nebraska Extension notes it uses little or no oil.

Air fryer vs convection oven vs oven air-fry mode, side by side

Many comparisons pit an air fryer against one kind of oven. The table below adds a third option many readers already own: the air-fry setting on a range or wall oven. Where no source gives a figure, the cell says so.

FeatureCountertop air fryerConvection oven (bake/roast)Oven air-fry modeSource
How heat movesElement above food, fan moves air quicklyFan circulates heated air through the cavityFast-moving hot air sent from above; fan cycles on and off (GE)Nebraska Extension; Consumer Reports; GE (manufacturer)
Element strengthVaries by model, check the manualNo figure in our sourcesFrigidaire says its Air Fry ranges’ convection element is more than twice as powerful as a standard oneFrigidaire (manufacturer claim)
Capacity2 to 6 qt basket (average range)About 18 qt average for convection toaster ovens; a range holds more than twice a standard air fryerSame cavity as the range, but meant for one rackPrudent Reviews; Consumer Reports; Frigidaire
Rack setupBasketSeveral racks, more than one food at onceOne rack; GE says center rack for most foodsFrigidaire; GE (manufacturer)
Typical settings350 to 400°F average400 to 450°F average (toaster oven)GE says to use the package’s oven temperature and timePrudent Reviews; GE (manufacturer)
PreheatAbout 4 min in one informal comparisonAbout 4 min in the same comparisonNone on GE’s No Preheat Air FryThe Spiffy Cookie (blog); GE (manufacturer)
Best atSmall batches of crispy foodBaking and roasting on several racksCrispy food on one rack; fries 20 to 30 min faster than bakeFrigidaire; Consumer Reports
Counter space103 to 172 sq in (4 models)196 to 376 sq in (3 toaster ovens)None; built into the rangePrudent Reviews, from listed dimensions

The capacity and temperature figures from Prudent Reviews are its stated averages, and the counter-space figures come from listed dimensions of popular models. Its cooking tests compared a 5.5-quart basket air fryer with a 16-quart convection toaster oven, not a full-size oven.

Is an air fryer faster than a convection oven?

Usually, by about 5 to 10 minutes in the few published side-by-side tests, but the evidence is thin. Three third-party sources report cook times, and none used the same method, so read them as rough signals.

FoodAir fryerComparison applianceTester and method
Chicken wings25 min35 min (convection toaster oven)Prudent Reviews, both in air-fry mode at 390°F
Frozen waffle fries15 min20 min (convection toaster oven)Prudent Reviews, both in air-fry mode at 350°F
Brussels sprouts13 minAbout 20 min (convection toaster oven)Prudent Reviews, both in air-fry mode at 390°F
Frozen friesCountertop fryer’s fries looked betterRange and wall-oven air-fry modes cut 20 to 30 min vs regular bakeConsumer Reports, 2 ranges and 1 wall oven
Fries, salmon, baconAbout 5 min fasterConvection oven, about 5 min slowerThe Spiffy Cookie, informal blog test

Each test has limits. Prudent Reviews used a toaster oven, and Consumer Reports compared air-fry mode with regular bake rather than with convection, crediting most of the gain to skipping the preheat. The blog test gave no wattage or model details.

Prudent Reviews also lists package directions, such as Ore-Ida fries at 400°F for 12 minutes in an air fryer vs 425°F for 25 to 29 minutes in a convection oven, but those are label instructions, not tests. No public test we found cooks the same food in a basket air fryer and a full-size convection oven head to head.

Convection vs the air fry setting on an oven: what’s the difference?

Per Frigidaire, Air Fry circulates hotter air sooner on one rack, while Convection heats more gradually for baking on several racks. Brands describe the two modes differently, so treat these as manufacturer statements.

Frigidaire says both modes use all the elements, burners and the convection fan, but the convection element in its Air Fry ranges is more than twice as powerful as a standard convection element. Air Fry heats up quickly and circulates hotter air sooner. Frigidaire says Air Fry is meant for one rack, while Convection is for baking and roasting on several racks.

GE Appliances describes its No Preheat Air Fry as fast-moving hot air sent from above to surround the food, with the fan cycling on and off. GE’s air-fry tips say to:

Consumer Reports also says dark bakeware absorbs more heat than shiny pans and helps food brown, and that a convection oven without an air-fry setting can get similar results on convection roast. Behavior differs by brand, so your owner’s manual is the final word on rack position and bakeware.

Air fryer or convection oven: which should you use?

Match the appliance to what and how much you cook:

For basket size by household, see what size air fryer you need. For picks, see the best air fryers.

Energy use: why the 20% figure doesn’t apply at home

You may see a “20% more efficient” figure attached to convection ovens. It comes from the ENERGY STAR commercial ovens factsheet, which says ENERGY STAR certified commercial convection ovens are about 20% more efficient than standard commercial models. It does not compare convection with regular baking or with an air fryer, and it does not cover home ranges.

None of our sources measured home energy use for either appliance. For per-use cost, see how much electricity an air fryer uses.

Food safety: the same temperatures either way

Nebraska Extension warns not to overfill an air fryer: food won’t cook evenly or reach the proper temperature, and it browns poorly. It says a food thermometer, placed in the thickest part away from bone, fat or gristle, is the only way to confirm meat, poultry and egg products are safe. It lists these USDA minimum internal temperatures, which apply whatever you cook in:

For coating and fire questions, see are air fryers safe.

More on air fryers

Frequently asked questions

Is an air fryer just a small convection oven?

In how it heats, yes. Nebraska Extension describes air frying as convection cooking, with a heating element above the food and a fan that moves hot air quickly. Consumer Reports says convection is the same technology behind countertop air fryers. Prudent Reviews credits the smaller chamber, closer element and faster fan for its speed.

Can I use the air fry setting on my oven instead of buying an air fryer?

Often, yes. Consumer Reports tested air-fry modes on two ranges and one wall oven, and all made golden, crispy fries with a few teaspoons of oil, 20 to 30 minutes faster than regular bake, largely because no preheat was needed. The fries were not quite as good-looking as from a countertop air fryer, but a range holds more than twice as much food.

What is the difference between convection and air fry on an oven?

Per Frigidaire, Air Fry makes hotter air sooner and is meant for one rack, while Convection is more gradual and meant for baking and roasting on several racks. Frigidaire says the convection element in its Air Fry ranges is more than twice as powerful as a standard one. GE says its air-fry mode sends fast-moving hot air from above, with the fan cycling on and off.

Do I need to preheat for oven air fry mode?

Not on GE's No Preheat Air Fry ranges and wall ovens. GE says to put food into a cold oven and start the mode, using the center rack for most foods and a lower rack for thicker ones. Other brands may differ, so check your oven's owner's manual before skipping preheat.

What pan should I use for air frying in a convection oven?

Use a dark baking or sheet pan. GE and Consumer Reports both say dark pans absorb more heat and brown food better than shiny ones. GE adds that parchment is fine, food should sit in a single layer without crowding, and a light spray of high-heat oil such as avocado oil helps crisping.

Sources

  1. food.unl.edu/sites/unl.edu.ianr.extension.food/files/articles/documents/food-safety-air-fryers-fffyc.pdf
  2. consumerreports.org/appliances/cooking-baking/how-to-air-fry-without-an-air-fryer-a3761040766
  3. owner.frigidaire.com/support-articles/article/1847377-ovens-what-is-the-difference-between-air-fry-and-convection-
  4. geappliances.com/ge/lifestyles/top-air-fry-oven-tips
  5. products.geappliances.com/appliance/gea-support-search-content
  6. energystar.gov/products/tools_resources/commercial-ovens-factsheet
  7. prudentreviews.com/air-fryer-vs-convection-toaster-oven
  8. thespiffycookie.com/2021/12/12/air-fryer-vs-convection-oven

Get new guides and recall alerts by email

About once a month. Unsubscribe in one click. Privacy